How to Handle a Bad Performance Review (When You're Blindsided)
About the episode
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Hearing you are "not strategic enough" after exceeding expectations is a red flag that requires deconstructing vague buzzwords.
- You must take a beat to process your anger before scheduling a recalibration conversation with your boss.
- Deal with performance shock using recalibration instead of spiraling into self-doubt.
- Turn a gut-punch into action by breaking down vague feedback into observable behaviors over three, six, nine, or twelve months.
- Push back on a vague development plan by getting a specific, documented plan that actually protects you.
- You should eventually give feedback to the CEO or manager who blindsided you with the review.
Timestamps:
01:10 — The listener's story: 15 years, then "not strategic enough"
03:17 — Step 1: Anger is okay — process it
04:20 — Step 2: Take a beat before you respond
04:33 — Step 3: Schedule the "recalibration" conversation
04:50 — Step 4: Deconstruct vague feedback (what does "strategic" mean?)
06:16 — Step 5: Get a specific, documented plan (3-6-9-12 months)
06:46 — Step 6: Growth mindset + find a mentor who's where you want to be
07:35 — Step 7: Give your CEO feedback — you were blindsided
09:01 — The bottom line: decode the criticism into action
Want to see how coaching can accelerate your life and career?
I'm Hannah
Executive Coach, columnist, podcaster, and speaker.
My mission is to help high-performing leaders become more confident, successful, and fulfilled in their careers.
The Ultimate Career Confidence Course
Discover how to show up with more confidence in high-pressure meetings, advocate for yourself at work, and be the leader you know you can be.
Executive Coaching
If you want to learn how executive coaching can further your confidence and career, schedule a call here.
